Nova Scotia Bikers Blog
Here we go again with the blog. This is a spot where you can voice your opinion - or ask a question... so feel free!
Entry for February 13, 2008
N.S. woman fined in accident that killed five people



By BEVERLEY WARE South Shore Bureau

Wed. Feb 13 - 5:03 PM

BRIDGEWATER – Roberta Haines has admitted crossing a double solid line in an accident that killed five people last May, including her own daughter.


Ms. Haines, 54, was not in Bridgewater provincial court this morning to enter the plea. She is apparently back in hospital for ongoing treatment of injuries she suffered in the accident.

Crown attorney Lloyd Tancock said an automatic conviction was entered late last year under the Motor Vehicle Act, but Ms. Haines had requested it be set aside.


But Mr. Tancock said he spoke with her Halifax lawyer Tuesday and Alex Keaveny said he is no longer opposing the automatic conviction.


Judge Anne Crawford immediately reinstated the conviction and gave Ms. Haines until April 9 to pay the $279.50 fine.


The ticket was issued Oct. 30, 2007, alleging Ms. Haines, who lives in Halifax, drove to the left of the double solid line on Highway 103 at the Blockhouse exit. She was driving a blue four-door 1996 Taurus owned by Dale Melanson.


Five people died in the accident and Ms. Haines was left in a coma for days.


When she woke, she learned her daughter Raella Haines, 22, who had been sitting beside her in the front, had been killed. Also killed were the four people who had been on the two motorcycles she hit: Gary Clarence Robar, 57, of Upper Branch, his daughter, Tanya Lousie Robar, 33, of Pine Grove, his common-law wife, Ann Louise Jodrey-Mailman, 57, and Ms. Robar's fiance, Mike Everett, 40.


Mr. Robar's son, Shawn Robar, is suing Roberta Haines, claiming she was speeding, driving recklessly and may have been impaired by drugs or alcohol at the time of the May 27 accident. In a defence filed with the Supreme Court in Bridgewater, Ms. Haines says such a claim is “frivolous and vexatious” and that Mr. Robar's father was the one at fault.


Shawn Robar is also suing Mr. Melanson alleging he failed to keep his car in proper working order.

2008-02-13 23:10:52 GMT
Comments (5 total)
Author:Anonymous
ummmm........it's mr robar's fault but it was haines who committed the act that caused the accident by crossing the centre line? has anybody told her to eat shit yet?
--ernie
2008-02-15 01:38:25 GMT
Author:Anonymous
"frivolous and vexatious" ... wow.. I guess it does take all kinds. I'm with Ernie on this one!
--Rhonda
2008-02-17 01:09:16 GMT
Author:Anonymous
While I do understand that sh!t happens, a person should take responsibility for said sh!t instead of blaming the motorcyclists. That being said may they all rest in piece.
--Matt
2008-02-21 23:25:29 GMT
Author:Anonymous
May Roberta Haines rest in peace also... Im sure it was not easy being in her situation.

~J
--Janice
<mailto:janice@novascotiabikers.com>
2008-03-11 16:07:02 GMT
Author:Anonymous
We shouldn't read a lot into the allegations that are contained in the legal actions. This is simply posturing by the respective lawyers who are void of compassion and stand to gain more financially then any of the parties concerned. In the final analysis after a period of time the Insurers will conclude that liablitity rests with the Melanson vehicle and settlements will be negotiated which will of course never come close to equitable compensation and the matter will be resolved with the affected parties to live the remainder of their lives with the void left by those they have lost. It's a fact of life that we may not particularly like but have no alternative but to live with it. Until the courts start addressing fatalities as the result of negligence behind the wheel of an automobile as manslaughter, more lives will be lost and the perpetrators will simply be addressed as victims who made a mistake, rather than criminally responsible as they should be.
--R. Salsman
<mailto:fxstb2000@hotmail.com>
2008-05-31 22:09:31 GMT
Compose a comment for this post.
Comment:
0 characters left (limit 4,000 characters). No HTML permitted.
Word verification:
To validate this comment, showing us that you are human, and not a computer, please retype the following code in the field provided.
(This helps prevent blog spam.)
Add to My Yahoo! RSS